Bad Thermostat or Water Pump in Your Car – How to Recognize the Symptoms Before it is Too Late

Maybe you’ve noticed something is off with your vehicle and you’re wondering whether the thermostat or water pump are on their way out. This article will guide you through the signs and symptoms that might indicate a faulty thermostat or water pump. With a little knowledge, you’ll be able to catch these issues early and save yourself from costly repairs or, worse, a broken-down car in the middle of your commute.

How to recognize a bad thermostat

The thermostat in your vehicle is a small, often overlooked, but extremely vital part. Its function is to regulate the engine’s temperature by controlling the flow of coolant from the radiator to the engine. When it’s working correctly, it ensures your engine operates at the optimal temperature. However, when it starts to fail, it can cause a range of problems. 

Here are some common signs:

  • Fluctuating Temperature Gauge: One of the first signs of a faulty thermostat is a temperature gauge that fluctuates wildly. If you notice your temperature needle bouncing between hot and cold rather than maintaining a steady reading, it may indicate that your thermostat is sticking open or closed at inappropriate times.
  • Overheating Engine: A thermostat stuck in the closed position will prevent coolant from circulating, causing your engine to overheat. This is often accompanied by steam coming from under the hood. If you notice this, pull over as soon as it is safe to do so to prevent severe engine damage.
  • Poor Fuel Efficiency: If the thermostat is stuck open, the engine will run cooler than it should. This can decrease your vehicle’s fuel efficiency as the engine control unit will inject more fuel to compensate for the low temperature.
  • Check Engine Light: Modern vehicles are equipped with numerous sensors. If your engine is consistently running too hot or too cold, it may trigger the check engine light. While this light can indicate a variety of issues, it’s worth considering the thermostat if it’s accompanied by any of the above symptoms.

How to recognize a bad water pump

The water pump plays a crucial role in your car’s cooling system by circulating coolant through the engine and radiator. A failing water pump can cause severe damage to your engine. Here are the key signs to watch for:

  • Coolant Leak: If you notice a green or orange fluid (typically the color of coolant) pooling under your car, it could indicate a leaking water pump. The weep hole, a safety feature in most pumps, will leak coolant when the pump is going bad.
  • Overheating Engine: Like a bad thermostat, a failing water pump can cause your engine to overheat. This is because the pump is no longer effectively circulating the coolant.
  • Whining or Groaning Noise: A water pump with a worn-out bearing can produce a high-pitched whining or groaning noise, especially when the vehicle is in idle. This noise can often be heard from the front of the engine.
  • Radiator Steam: If your pump isn’t circulating coolant properly, it can cause the engine to overheat, resulting in steam coming out of your radiator. If you notice this, it’s crucial to stop driving immediately to avoid severe engine damage.


A car’s thermostat is a small device that sits between the engine and the radiator. Its job is to block the flow of coolant to the radiator until the engine has warmed up.

When a thermostat fails, it can stick in either an open or closed position. If it’s stuck open, the engine runs cold, affecting performance and fuel efficiency. If it’s stuck closed, the engine overheats, which can cause severe damage.

There isn’t a set interval for replacing the thermostat. However, it’s a good idea to replace it whenever you have major cooling system maintenance, such as a radiator or water pump replacement.

While the car might still run with a bad thermostat, it’s not advisable. A faulty thermostat can cause the engine to overheat or run inefficiently, leading to more severe issues down the line.

The water pump is a crucial part of the car’s cooling system. It circulates coolant from the radiator, through the engine, and back to the radiator to maintain optimal engine temperature.

Common signs of a bad water pump include coolant leaks, an overheating engine, whining noises from the engine, and steam coming from the radiator.

Most water pumps should last between 60,000 and 90,000 miles. However, it’s a good idea to consult your vehicle’s manual for manufacturer-specific recommendations.

It’s not advisable to drive with a bad water pump as it can lead to your engine overheating, which can cause severe damage.

The cost of replacing a thermostat can vary depending on the make and model of your vehicle. On average, you can expect to pay between $200 and $300, including parts and labor.

The cost of a water pump replacement can also vary widely, typically between £300 and £750, including parts and labor.

Yes, a malfunctioning thermostat can trigger the check engine light on your dashboard.

While less common, in some cases, a faulty water pump can cause the check engine light to illuminate.

While the thermostat mainly affects the engine’s temperature, a malfunctioning one can indirectly affect the AC if it causes the engine to overheat.

Yes, a failing water pump often makes a high-pitched whining or groaning noise, especially when the vehicle is idling.

Generally, replacing a thermostat takes about 1-2 hours, depending on the complexity of the vehicle’s design.

A water pump replacement can take anywhere from 3 to 5 hours, again depending on the complexity of the vehicle’s design.

While a bad water pump primarily affects engine temperature, if it causes the engine to run hotter than normal, it can indirectly affect fuel economy.

Yes, a bad thermostat that causes the engine to run cooler than normal can decrease fuel efficiency because the engine control unit will inject more fuel to compensate for the low temperature.

No, it’s not normal for a water pump to leak. If you notice a leak, it’s often a sign that the water pump is failing and you should have it looked into as soon as possible. 

If you have a decent knowledge of car mechanics, it is possible to replace a thermostat or water pump yourself. Also with older cars it it much simple to do this yourself, with new cars it can get quite complex so if you are not confident, it is best to leave these tasks to a professional to avoid causing further damage to your vehicle.

The Car Stuff